Survey Pinpoints Challenges to Increasing Safety Performance

For safety training, quality appears to be more important than quantity, according to a study conducted by Environmental Resources Management (ERM). The 2018 Global Safety Survey examined responses from 144 safety leaders from 120 corporations in 22 countries. Approximately 20% of the respondents were from oil and gas companies.

Brian Kraus, global managing partner for safety transformation services with ERM, summed up the results of the survey. “It’s not about doing more on safety,” he said. “It’s about getting more from what you do already.”

Kraus presented key insights from the survey through an online seminar held by the Society of Petroleum Engineers (SPE). The seminar was moderated by Trey Shaffer, senior partner with ERM.

The survey was conducted as a series of 1-hour phone interviews and was designed to elicit subjective opinions. During the presentation, Kraus expounded on nine key findings.

  • Stakeholder expectations are rising.
  • Companies are increasing their investment in safety.
  • Significant cultural and performance challenges remain.
  • Risk continues to shift to contractors.
  • Most companies do not understand how much they are investing in safety.
  • Lagging performance indicators remain dominant.
  • Established safety processes and programs are not having a sufficient effect on performance.
  • Harnessing data and technology is becoming a major focus.
  • Leadership engagement is key, but leaders need to step up and gain new skills.

Stakeholder Expectations
Of the survey’s respondents, 88% said they have seen increased pressure from stakeholders to increase safety, and 62% said they thought regulators were taking a stronger stance on safety.

Increasing Investment
Companies appear to be spending more on safety than they had in the past; 78% of respondents said they had increased their level of investment in safety over the past year. Looking to the future, 82% of respondents said they are planning to increase investment in safety over the next 3 years. That increase in spending, however, may not produce the large results employers are seeking. Other data from the survey show only a slight increase in safety performance associated with increased spending. “There is no statistical evidence in the data of a correlation between the level of spending and value derived,” Kraus said during the presentation.

Cultural and Performance Challenges
Companies, however, are eager to boost their safety performance; 59% of the survey’s respondents say their safety performance is unacceptable, while only 33% said they had the safety performance they want. Efforts to increase safety performance appear to have the greatest effect when the focus is on the front lines. “The companies with the most robust peer-on-peer engagement have the strongest safety cultures,” Kraus said.

Contractor Risk
Many respondents said the use of contractors presents a weak spot in their safety performance. Nearly a quarter of the respondents reported an increasing use of contractors, and two-thirds said they see contractor safety as more challenging than managing safety for their own employees. One of the reasons for this challenge, Kraus said, appears to be variability in safety cultures between contractors and their host companies. Nearly all of the respondents, however, said they see opportunities to mitigate this by addressing safety better throughout the contractor-engagement life cycle, especially in the earlier stages.

Understanding Safety Investment
When asked to estimate what their company spends on safety as a percentage of labor costs, oil and gas companies ranked the highest, at 26%. The average was 17%. “That tells us that organizations are spending vast amounts of resources on safety programs,” Kraus said. However, when asked how many hours of training was provided per employee, many respondents did not know. From the respondents who could provide an answer, the average was 26 hours, which amounts to 1.5% of average annual hours worked.

Lagging Indicators
One of the key recommendation of SPE’s recent technical report “Getting to Zero” was to de-emphasize lagging indicators in favor of leading indicators for safety. The results of this survey show industry still has a long way to go. “Most are still using lagging indicators—that is, accident reports,” Kraus said. Only a quarter of respondents reported using leading indicators to measure safety performance.

Established Processes
Higher levels of training appeared to correlate with positive perspectives on a company’s safety culture, but many said the training they used was not affecting the behavior of their employees. “We were staggered that 40% said that safety training was not affecting the thinking of their people,” Kraus said. “The data indicated that the effectiveness of training is a better predictor of performance than the number of hours of training.”

Kraus pointed out that no statistical evidence existed to support the idea that implementing a fatality-prevention program has an effect on the number of years since the last serious injury or fatality. “We are suggesting that companies need to put more effort in extracting value from their training,” he said.

Data and Technology
As in all aspects of industry, data and technology stay at the forefront of safety. Nearly all of the survey’s respondents said they see harnessing technology and data as vital to improving safety performance. Three-quarters said they have a formal 1- to 2-year strategic priority of increasing the use of technology and data to improve safety performance.

Three-quarters of respondents identified leadership engagement at all levels as the most effective means of delivering behavioral change on the front lines. However, “The respondents broadly believe that their leaders are not sufficiently engaged in safety,” Kraus said. “Leadership engagement is key—in fact, probably the key,” he added. “But leaders need to step up, and they need new skills.”

Find the presentation here.



Don't miss our latest HSE content, delivered to your inbox twice monthly. Sign up for the HSE Now newsletter.  If you are not logged in, you will receive a confirmation email that you will need to click on to confirm you want to receive the newsletter.





HSE Now is a source for news and technical information affecting the health, safety, security, environment, and social responsibility discipline of the upstream oil and gas industry.