Helicopter Transport Still "Biggest Concern" a Decade After Super Puma Tragedy

Credit: Raymond Besant.
Before a game against Inverness Caley Thistle at Pittodrie Stadium in Aberdeen, fans hold signs bearing the names of the crew and passengers who died in the Super Puma crash 10 years ago.

The oil and gas industry is today marking 10 years since a Bond Super Puma helicopter came down 12 miles off the coast of Peterhead, Scotland, killing all 14 passengers and two crew members on board.

A fatal accident inquiry (FAI) found the crash came as a result of a catastrophic gearbox failure and was preventable had Bond followed the correct maintenance procedures.

Seven years later, another Super Puma crashed off the Norwegian island of Turoy, killing 13 people. Investigators flagged “similarities” with the 2009 incident, with gearbox faults identified in both.

The Super Puma has since been removed from North Sea oil and gas operations, and safety body HeliOffshore said its members are working tirelessly to prevent any further incidents.

However, Jake Molloy, regional officer of the RMT union in Aberdeen, said a lack of confidence in helicopter transport remains a huge issue.

“It is still the biggest concern,” he said.

“When you’re living and working on a gas plant, where the potential for a disaster is huge, it beggars belief that their biggest concern is their transport to and from that place of work.”

Industry body Oil and Gas UK said the anniversary serves as a “stark reminder” that the sector can never become complacent.

A total of 33 people have been killed in Super Puma crashes in the North Sea in the last decade.

This has led to repeated calls from RMT and the Unite union for a Westminster-backed public inquiry into helicopter safety and whether commercial pressures are affecting safety, such as appropriate time being taken to maintain and service the aircraft.

Aviation safety is reserved to the UK, and the Scottish Government last month decided not to back an inquiry, stating that work is already under way within the industry to review safety.

This includes the Civil Aviation Authority’s post-implementation review of measures put in place after a crash off Sumburgh, Scotland, in 2013.

Fatal Accident Inquiry

The FAI  into the 2009 crash only took place 5 years later. Families of the Sumburgh crash victims are still waiting for one.

An FAI is only launched if there is no prospect of a criminal prosecution.

Unions and family members have maintained that someone should be held to account for for the 2009 crash.

Molloy added, “This has been an issue about corporate accountability. It’s been running since Piper Alpha in 1988.

“The argument in law, in Scotland at least, is this identifying the ‘knowing mind,’ the person who knew that this was an inevitable outcome. Who would that be?

“Justice is rarely, if ever, seen to be done. And, quite frankly, I think with the accident in 2009, I would go so far as to say someone should be in prison for what happened.”

Read the full story here.



Don't miss our latest HSE content, delivered to your inbox twice monthly. Sign up for the HSE Now newsletter.  If you are not logged in, you will receive a confirmation email that you will need to click on to confirm you want to receive the newsletter.





HSE Now is a source for news and technical information affecting the health, safety, security, environment, and social responsibility discipline of the upstream oil and gas industry.